What are Two Disadvantages to Asphalt Shingles?

• April 30, 2025
• Categories: Blog, Roofing

Asphalt shingles have long been the go-to roofing material for homeowners across the United States. They’re affordable, easy to install, and available in various styles and colors. But let’s not sugarcoat it—while they offer convenience and a decent lifespan, they’re not perfect. If you’re considering this roofing option, you need to weigh the pros and cons before making a long-term decision. This article explores two key disadvantages to asphalt shingles, along with some insights into making the right roofing choice for your home in Woodlands.

And most importantly, we’ll explain why choosing a Proper Roof Replacement Contractor in Woodlands can make all the difference, especially when dealing with the downsides of asphalt shingles.

What Are Asphalt Shingles?

Before diving into the downsides, let’s quickly cover what asphalt shingles actually are. These roofing materials are made of a base (often fiberglass), covered with a layer of asphalt for waterproofing, and topped with ceramic granules for durability and UV protection.

There are three main types:

• 3-tab shingles – budget-friendly and basic 
• Architectural shingles – more durable with a layered look 
• Luxury shingles – mimic high-end roofing materials like slate 

Now that you’ve got the basics down, let’s talk about where things can go wrong.

Disadvantage #1: Shorter Lifespan Compared to Other Materials

Here’s the thing—asphalt shingles just don’t last as long as other roofing options like metal, tile, or slate. Typically, asphalt shingles will last around 15 to 30 years, depending on weather, quality, and installation. In a humid, storm-prone area like Woodlands, that lifespan may shrink even more.

Why is this a problem?

• Frequent replacements: If you plan to stay in your home long-term, you may find yourself replacing the roof more than once. 
• Higher cumulative cost: While the initial price tag might be lower, the need for multiple replacements can actually end up costing more than investing in a more durable material upfront. 
• Environmental impact: Asphalt shingles aren’t the most eco-friendly option. More replacements mean more landfill waste. 

Many homeowners make the mistake of choosing asphalt just because it’s cheaper. But when the roof starts to age or deteriorate faster than expected, the regret sets in. This is where hiring a Proper Roof Replacement Contractor in Woodlands becomes critical. An experienced contractor can assess if asphalt is the right fit for your specific home and climate—or recommend a longer-lasting alternative.

Disadvantage #2: Susceptibility to Weather Damage

Another big issue? Asphalt shingles are easily damaged by extreme weather. If you’ve ever experienced hailstorms, heavy rains, or intense sun exposure, you already know how hard that can be on a roof.

How do they react to different weather conditions?

• Hail and Wind: Shingles can crack, lift, or even fly off entirely during high winds or hailstorms. 
• Heat and Sun: Constant UV exposure can dry them out, causing curling, blistering, and fading. 
• Humidity: In humid climates like Woodlands, algae and moss growth are common problems that can stain and degrade your roof. 

Once shingles begin to warp or deteriorate, water can seep underneath, leading to mold growth, leaks, and even structural damage.

That’s why a Proper Roof Replacement Contractor in Woodlands will not only install the shingles correctly but also recommend protective underlayment, ridge vents, and other materials that enhance the roof’s durability. Plus, they’ll guide you on proper maintenance to extend the life of your roof, even with asphalt.

Additional Drawbacks Worth Considering

Though we’re focusing on two primary disadvantages, a few other things are worth keeping in mind:

• Aesthetic Limitations: While they come in various colors, asphalt shingles can’t compete with the beauty of tile, cedar, or slate. 
• Energy Efficiency: They tend to absorb heat, which can drive up cooling costs during hot Texas summers. 
• Not Ideal for Low-Slope Roofs: Water runoff is less effective on shallow slopes, increasing the risk of leaks. 

When Are Asphalt Shingles Still a Good Option?

Despite the disadvantages, asphalt shingles might still make sense for certain homeowners:

• You’re on a tight budget 
• You plan to sell within 5–10 years 
• You’re working with a skilled contractor 
• You live in a mild-weather area 

If any of these apply to you, asphalt shingles can be a practical choice—as long as they’re installed by a Proper Roof Replacement Contractor in Woodlands. A trusted contractor can help mitigate some of the risks through smart installation and upgrades.

Comparing Asphalt to Other Roofing Materials

Let’s break down how asphalt shingles stack up against other popular options:

Clearly, asphalt loses when it comes to durability and longevity. But its affordability and ease of installation still make it attractive—especially if your roof is due for a quick replacement and you’re not looking for something long-term.

How to Make Asphalt Shingles Work For You

You don’t need to avoid asphalt shingles altogether. The key is to optimize your investment by:

1. Choosing high-quality shingles from reputable brands 
2. Adding protective features, like algae-resistant granules or UV-blocking layers 
3. Maintaining your roof regularly – clearing debris, inspecting for damage, and resealing if necessary 
4. Hiring the right contractor 

And that brings us full circle. The smartest thing you can do is work with a Proper Roof Replacement Contractor in Woodlands who knows the ins and outs of the local climate, roofing materials, and installation best practices. They’ll steer you away from cheap fixes and help you make an informed decision.

10 FAQs About Asphalt Shingles

1. Are asphalt shingles suitable for all climates?
   Not really. They perform best in moderate climates. In hot, humid, or storm-prone areas, they tend to wear out faster.
2. How often should asphalt shingles be replaced?
   Typically every 20–25 years, though high-quality architectural shingles can last closer to 30 years.
3. Can I install asphalt shingles myself?
   Technically yes, but it’s not recommended. Mistakes can void warranties and lead to leaks. Always use a professional contractor.
4. What causes asphalt shingles to curl or crack?
   Age, UV exposure, poor ventilation, and moisture buildup are common causes.
5. Do asphalt shingles increase home value?
   They might maintain value but rarely increase it significantly unless the roof is brand new.
6. Are there eco-friendly asphalt shingles?
   Yes, some are made with recycled materials, but they’re still less sustainable than metal or clay options.
7. What’s the cost to replace an asphalt shingle roof?
   In Woodlands, it typically ranges from $4,000 to $12,000 depending on roof size and shingle quality.
8. Can asphalt shingles be repaired or must they always be replaced?
   Small sections can be repaired, but widespread damage usually calls for full replacement.
9. Are asphalt shingles fire-resistant?
   Fiberglass-based shingles offer Class A fire resistance, the highest rating.
10. How do I find a Proper Roof Replacement Contractor in Woodlands?
    Look for licensed, insured companies with great reviews and local experience—like Roof Replacement Group.

Final Thoughts

Asphalt shingles come with their fair share of pros and cons. While they’re affordable and accessible, the two main disadvantages—shorter lifespan and vulnerability to weather—are worth serious consideration. If you’re living in Woodlands, where weather can be unpredictable and humid, you’ll want to be especially cautious.

The solution? Don’t go it alone. Work with a Proper Roof Replacement Contractor in Woodlands who understands the local climate and can install your roof with care, precision, and future durability in mind. Whether you decide to go with asphalt shingles or explore other options, the right contractor can turn a good roof into a great one.